Friday, October 29, 2010
one book (hopefully) stays, one book's a maybe
Happy Friday! Two new stories have come to my attention via ALA's Office for Intellectual Freedom. One in Appleton and one in Belleville, both regarding recent book challenges. Each of these events is rather sad since in both cases, the parents decided that instead of simply opting their own children out of reading the books, they feel they need to push their parenting styles on all students. The first is an article, written by Kathy Nufer on PostCrescent.com. A parent challenged the the book The Body of Christopher Creed:
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
No First Amendment protection for Teachers
"Teachers have no First Amendment free-speech protection for curricular decisions they make in the classroom," a federal appeals court ruled on October 21st, according to an Education Week article on School Law. The following are excerpts from the article:
"Only the school board has ultimate responsibility for what goes on in the classroom, legitimately giving it a say over what teachers may (or may not) teach in the classroom," the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit, in Cincinnati, said in its opinion.
The decision came in the case of an Ohio teacher whose contract was not renewed in 2002 after community controversy over reading selections she assigned to her high school English classes. These included Siddhartha , by Herman Hesse, and a unit on book censorship in which the teacher allowed students to pick books from a list of frequently challenged works, and some students chose Heather Has Two Mommies, by Leslea Newman.
"When a teacher teaches, the school system does not regulate that speech as much as it hires that speech," Sutton wrote, borrowing language from a 7th Circuit decision in a similar case. "Expression is a teacher's stock in trade, the commodity she sells to her employer in exchange for a salary. And if it is the school board that hires that speech, it can surely regulate the content of what is or is not expressed, what is expressed in other words on its behalf."
What do you think of this decision? Does it limit the abilities of teachers to make decisions in the classroom to best suit individual classrooms? What sort of impact do you think this decision will have on teachers in the future, if any?
"Only the school board has ultimate responsibility for what goes on in the classroom, legitimately giving it a say over what teachers may (or may not) teach in the classroom," the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit, in Cincinnati, said in its opinion.
The decision came in the case of an Ohio teacher whose contract was not renewed in 2002 after community controversy over reading selections she assigned to her high school English classes. These included Siddhartha , by Herman Hesse, and a unit on book censorship in which the teacher allowed students to pick books from a list of frequently challenged works, and some students chose Heather Has Two Mommies, by Leslea Newman.
"When a teacher teaches, the school system does not regulate that speech as much as it hires that speech," Sutton wrote, borrowing language from a 7th Circuit decision in a similar case. "Expression is a teacher's stock in trade, the commodity she sells to her employer in exchange for a salary. And if it is the school board that hires that speech, it can surely regulate the content of what is or is not expressed, what is expressed in other words on its behalf."
What do you think of this decision? Does it limit the abilities of teachers to make decisions in the classroom to best suit individual classrooms? What sort of impact do you think this decision will have on teachers in the future, if any?
Friday, October 22, 2010
We all knew it was coming
We all knew it was coming ever since the books became a hit only a short time ago. The Hunger Games are now under fire in New Hampshire from a parent who objects to the story being read aloud to her daughter. Lauren Barack wrote about it in an article for the School Library Journal on October 19th:
A New Hampshire parent has asked the Goffstown School Board to remove Suzanne Collins's The Hunger Games (Scholastic, 2008) from her daughter's class, claiming that it gave her 11-year-old nightmares and could numb other students to the effects of violence.I remember when I used to be afraid of dinosaurs and my grade 5 class was watching Jurassic Park during a class party. I saw the opening sequence in which the guard gets eaten and was traumatized for a good two weeks. My parents were concerned about me, but did they go to the school board and ask that every child be kept from watching scary movies? No, because it's up to me and my parents to decide what kind of things frighten me and therefore it is up to us to decide what I should watch. And my mom even watched Jurassic Park, so she knew what was going on. In this case, however, the parents hasn't even bothered to read the book. And she has decided to try and make everyone else follow her parenting style:
To censorship expert Pat Scales, the main concern is one parent attempting to set policy for the children of others. And this challenge, which comes on the heels of the American Library Association's (ALA) Banned Book Week, is a cautionary tale other parents should note, she adds.
"When a parent objects to a book being taught, a lot of school districts say a parent can take a child out," says Scales, a former school librarian and member of ALA's Intellectual Freedom Committee. "And a lot of parents have an objection because they say their child is being singled out. But you have already singled your child out. And no parent has a right to select the curriculum."The principal has gathered a review committee, much like the committee which just finished reviewing Kaffir Boy in San Luis Obispo. The committee has 30 days to review the book and report their findings. This is being done even in the absence of a formal request for review from the parent. This is all being done in good faith from the school. They are not, however, bowing to the parent's wishes as has happened in some circumstances:
Although the school district requests that formal book challenges be handled by filling out a request for reconsideration form, LaSalle has yet to do so. To date, The Hunger Games is still being read in class, and LaSalle's daughter is removed from class during that time. Three copies of the book remain in the school library.The article states that "Mrs. LaSalle asked what this book teaches students as far as honor, ethics, and morals. Mrs. LaSalle stated there is no lesson in this book except if you are a teenager and kill twenty-three other teenagers, you win the game and your family wins." This parent has obviously never bothered to look at critical reviews or hear opinions from others because there is a lot about morals, and honor, and ethics in the book. I'm hoping that the committee will see it the way Scales presented the argument in the quotations above, and that they will therefore keep the book in circulation at the school and in classrooms.
Wednesday, October 20, 2010
Finally, some good news
In an act of pure sensibility, the review committee at San Luis Obispo High School that was charged with deciding the fate of Kaffir Boy (written about earlier this month here), voted unanimously to keep the book both in the school library and in the honors program curriculum. Pat Pemberton, writing for the San Luis Obispo Tribune recapped the situation, saying,
There was a suggestion that there be a revised copy of the text used, that didn't contain the graphic details of the original, but that was removed from discussion early on.
The principal had put together a 7 person review committee shortly after the complaint. The committee met with an audience of 50 people, including students, teachers, and parents. Pemberton writes,Controversy arose when anonymous letters complaining about “Kaffir Boy” were sent to [history teacher Carrie] Zinn, school administrators and the school board. The letters complained specifically about a single page describing boys prostituting themselves for food.
These concerns are certainly not unfounded, especially considering the challenge that recently occurred in Florida, where a mother requested that her son's school ban Catcher in the Rye because it took the Lord's name in vain and used to many "f" words. Hopefully the review committee in that case will look at the handling of this situation and will not allow a single parent to limit what every student in the school reads.A few said high school students were old enough to handle the language used — one student suggested she heard similar language daily. And a couple of teachers expressed concern that banning “Kaffir Boy” would lead to challenges to other books, including classics such as J.D. Salinger’s “The Catcher in the Rye.”
There was a suggestion that there be a revised copy of the text used, that didn't contain the graphic details of the original, but that was removed from discussion early on.
Any comments, thoughts, or rants about this story? I, for one, applaud the common sense of the individuals on this reviewing committee and congratulate them on their unanimous vote to keep the book in the curriculum.While teacher John Franklin suggested that the abridged version still conveyed the horrors of apartheid, others contended an edited version whitewashes history and disrespects victims of segregation.
Monday, October 18, 2010
the unintelligible mess that is book banning...
Marcus Smith, in an article on The Daily Cougar, wrote an article at the closing of Banned Books Week 2010, talking about some of the unintelligible reasons for banning or challenging books. Some books are challenged based on sincere concerns which, unfortunately, tend to breach American First Amendment rights, but many are challenged for seriously stupid reasons. Smith writes:
In his article, Smith brings forward a very absurd challenge that is enough to make me wonder if the majority of book challengers even use common sense.
Book banning is rarely done on the basis of logic or thoughtful consideration, but more so on ignorance and prejudice. When books are banned for absurd reasons such as pro-communism in George Orwell’s “1984” or pro-racism in Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird,” — the exact opposite of what these books advocate — you’re left wondering if some people have even read the books they challenge.I don't often wonder, because in so many cases it's proven the challengers haven't read the texts, based solely on the argument brought forward in the challenge. In the examples listed above, it is obvious that the challenger either didn't bother reading the text, or they are just unable to bring a critical eye to the reading experience.
In his article, Smith brings forward a very absurd challenge that is enough to make me wonder if the majority of book challengers even use common sense.
The Texas Board of Education [...] banned the children’s picture book “Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?” by Bill Martin, a book that helps toddlers learn about colors and associate meaning to them. The reasoning behind this was that they confused the author with another Bill Martin, author of “Ethical Marxism: The Categorical Imperative of Liberation” despite the fact that a simple glance at the book would have prevented this.Silly, you say? I concur. This seems to be a lesson about the emphasis we place on political correctness rather than critical thought. Books are meant to encourage thoughts and ideas, which they cannot do if they are challenged and kept away from children's curious hands.
Book banning does not protect children; it harms them, chiefly by attempting to instill political correctness or agendas and ignoring a novel’s core meaning and values. When books are banned and kept out of the grasp of children, you effectively limit their potential understanding of the world through other viewpoints.Thanks Mr. Smith for your intelligent analysis of the effects of keeping books away from Children for truly ridiculous reasons.
Friday, October 15, 2010
At least learn how to write...
I am all for expression and encourage people express their opinions about literature in whatever way they feel necessary, as long as it doesn't obstruct others from making their own opinions. That's the point of this blog. I want to encourage people to see the impracticality and destruction caused by certain groups or individuals by trying to limit access to books and other forms of literature (graphic novels, films, plays, etc.) This week I was wandering the unlimited hallways of the internet, trying to find content for today's post. I came across an opinion piece on News-Leader.com.
Wesley Scroggins is an associate professor of management at Missouri State University, and he wrote this article criticizing book choices in classrooms. He claims that "In high school English classes, children are required to read and view material that should be classified as soft pornography." The books specifically targeted are Speak, Twenty Boy Summer, and Slaughterhouse Five. The article is frightening enough simply because Mr. Scroggins is trying to limit access to literature and knowledge. He doesn't just stick with High School but also spotlights sex-education classes in all grades. Where am I going with this, you ask? If you read the article, I'm sure you'll understand. I'm trying to say that if you're going to share your opinion, at least learn how to write a sentence!!!
Mr. Scroggins... I'm sorry, Dr. Scroggins, writes sentences that would cause certain grammar critics to feel faint. An entire blog post on The Rejectionist is devoted to the horrific grammatical errors that cause one to laugh rather than take anything he says seriously. Here's one example from The Rejectionist's blog entry. The bold is from the original article:
Laurie Halse Anderson spoke out against Mr. Scroggins on her own blog:
Thank you to Laurie Halse Anderson for her well-written and grammatically correct response. And to reiterate, I do not hold anything against Dr. Scroggins if he wishes to be of the opinion that Speak and Slaughterhouse Five are soft pornography. What I am against is the idea that because he holds these opinions, others should not be allowed to read the literature. That is what truly scares me; that people who can't take the time to write a strong argument are being listened to and are able to impose limitations onto others.
Care to share your thoughts and opinions? Feel free to talk about the original article's meaning or the horrible construction of it, The Rejectionist's blog post, or Laurie Halse Anderson's response. It's all fair game.
Wesley Scroggins is an associate professor of management at Missouri State University, and he wrote this article criticizing book choices in classrooms. He claims that "In high school English classes, children are required to read and view material that should be classified as soft pornography." The books specifically targeted are Speak, Twenty Boy Summer, and Slaughterhouse Five. The article is frightening enough simply because Mr. Scroggins is trying to limit access to literature and knowledge. He doesn't just stick with High School but also spotlights sex-education classes in all grades. Where am I going with this, you ask? If you read the article, I'm sure you'll understand. I'm trying to say that if you're going to share your opinion, at least learn how to write a sentence!!!
Mr. Scroggins... I'm sorry, Dr. Scroggins, writes sentences that would cause certain grammar critics to feel faint. An entire blog post on The Rejectionist is devoted to the horrific grammatical errors that cause one to laugh rather than take anything he says seriously. Here's one example from The Rejectionist's blog entry. The bold is from the original article:
Another sentence that proved quite difficult to interpret was as follows:
The content ranges from naked men and women in cages together so that others can watch them having sex to God telling people that they better not mess with his loser, bum of a son, named Jesus Christ.The comma, Dr. Scroggins, is a friend, not a foe; and a loyal, staunch friend it may be to a writer who treats it with the respect and admiration it is due. Yet you, sir, appear determined here to heap upon this hardworking little ally all manner of abuses; unsurprisingly, in your hour of need the comma has betrayed you, thanks to your callous disregard for its proper employ.
Perhaps this is going to get taken as me just being rude. But that is not the case at all! I simply think that if you are going to go to the trouble of making random claims in an attempt to place limitations on what people can read, the least you can do is put together a thoughtful comment, and check your spelling. Dr. Scroggins, unfortunately, did none of the above. Of course he also thinks that the sex is Speak is bad for High School students to read. The sex that takes place is rape. It's tragic, not sexy. Come on, Dr. Scroggins, there's this thing called context!In this book, drunken teens also end up on the beach, where they use their condoms to have sex.And how, pray tell, does a drunken teen use “condoms to have sex”? We consider ourselves pretty worldly, good sir, but we are quite baffled as to the exact logistics involved in “us[ing] their condoms to have sex.” Perhaps you are more well-versed in the vagaries of kink than this innocent Rejectionist, Dr. Scroggins. A little light shed on the technicalities of this activity would be most useful, as we are left here to our imagination, which we must admit is failing us entirely.
Laurie Halse Anderson spoke out against Mr. Scroggins on her own blog:
My fear is that good-hearted people in Scroggins’ community will read his piece and believe what he says. And then they will complain to the school board. And then the book will be pulled and then all those kids who might have found truth and support in the book will be denied that. In addition, all the kids who have healthy emotional lives but who hate reading, will miss the chance to enjoy a book that might change their opinion.
Thank you to Laurie Halse Anderson for her well-written and grammatically correct response. And to reiterate, I do not hold anything against Dr. Scroggins if he wishes to be of the opinion that Speak and Slaughterhouse Five are soft pornography. What I am against is the idea that because he holds these opinions, others should not be allowed to read the literature. That is what truly scares me; that people who can't take the time to write a strong argument are being listened to and are able to impose limitations onto others.Care to share your thoughts and opinions? Feel free to talk about the original article's meaning or the horrible construction of it, The Rejectionist's blog post, or Laurie Halse Anderson's response. It's all fair game.
Wednesday, October 13, 2010
in other news...
Also in the news this week is the re-classification of a book at the Waukee Public Library. The DesMoinesRegister.com notes that "'The Notebook Girls,' a diary cataloging the real-life experiences of four New York City high school girls, will now be housed with the library's adult nonfiction collection." This comes in response to a book challenge last month about foul language in the text. The article also notes that the book originally "created a stir in the publishing world with its frank discussions about adolescent sex, drinking and drug use when it was released in 2006."
The book is a diary-style account of the lives of four girls living in New York. Do we really expect it to be devoid of any sort of language or sexuality? And if so, why would it be published if there was no public desire for books with such content? There is obviously a market, so should we make the book disappear because it appeals to it's demographic? I think not.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)